Millions of Americans consistently struggle with sleeplessness, reporting symptoms of insomnia such as difficulty falling or remaining asleep at night. According to a nationally representative survey, only 43% of Americans rate their sleep quality as good or very good. This widespread issue has profound health consequences, linking insufficient rest to increased risks of conditions like obesity, diabetes, hypertension, coronary artery disease, heart failure, stroke, anxiety, and depression. Seeking remedies, approximately one in six Americans are turning to dietary or Natural Supplements for sleep improvement, preferring these over-the-counter options to prescription medications.
Natural Supplements are available in various forms, including pills, teas, and tonics, and are marketed to promote rest and relaxation. As they are typically regulated as dietary supplements, their quality and purity can vary widely due due to a lack of strict federal regulations, making it essential to look for trustworthy certification seals from organizations like U.S. Pharmacopeia, ConsumerLab.com, or NSF to ensure quality and safety. Understanding the evidence behind specific supplements can help consumers make informed choices regarding their efforts to improve sleep.
🌙 Quick Tip: If you struggle to fall asleep quickly, you might love Sleep Hacking, a 5-step, science-backed program developed by Dr. Marcus Rivera. It retrains your brain’s nighttime alert system so you fall asleep in about 10 minutes.
👉 Learn more here: Sleep Hacking
Ashwagandha: Significant Effects on Sleep Quality and Latency
One herbal therapy currently under rigorous investigation for insomnia is Withania somnifera, commonly known as Ashwagandha. Used for centuries in Ayurveda (traditional Indian medicine), this plant extract has demonstrated anti-stress, anti-anxiety, and rejuvenating properties.
A systematic review and meta-analysis of five randomized controlled trials revealed that Ashwagandha extract exhibited a small but significant effect on overall sleep compared to placebo. The effects were more pronounced in specific subgroups:
• Insomnia Diagnosis: The improvement in overall sleep was more prominent in adults who had been diagnosed with insomnia.
• Dosage and Duration: For maximum benefit, the effects were more substantial with treatment dosages of 600 mg/day or more and treatment durations of eight weeks or longer.
Studies showed Ashwagandha significantly improved several objective and subjective measures of sleep. For instance, Ashwagandha extract improved sleep onset latency (the time taken to fall asleep) and total sleep time. It also reduced wake time after sleep onset (WASO) and improved sleep efficiency. Additionally, taking Ashwagandha extract was found to significantly improve mental alertness on rising and reduce anxiety levels.
Ashwagandha appears to be generally well tolerated. Clinical trials reported no serious adverse effects. Mild adverse events reported included viral fever, headache, acid reflux, and allergic dermatitis. The two main extracts studied were KSM-66 (root extract) and Shoden® (root and leaves extract).
Melatonin: Timing, Efficacy, and Safety Concerns
Melatonin is perhaps the most widely recognized natural supplement used to improve sleep. This naturally produced hormone regulates sleep-wake cycles and controls feelings of sleepiness and alertness. Melatonin supplements signal to the brain that it is time for sleep.
Limited Efficacy for Chronic Insomnia
Research suggests melatonin supplementation can help people fall asleep approximately seven minutes faster on average. Its primary benefit is related to adjusting the body’s natural circadian phase, making it potentially beneficial for people experiencing jet lag or certain sleep disorders.
However, for individuals suffering from chronic insomnia, the American Academy of Sleep Medicine (AASM) guidelines recommend against the use of melatonin as a first-line option due to limited and low-quality evidence. Furthermore, studies suggest that long-term, immediate-release forms have limited utility for sleep maintenance, though prolonged-release versions have shown modest benefits in older adults (aged 55 years and older) whose endogenous production naturally declines.
Long-Term Safety Signals
While often perceived as harmless, recent data challenges the safety perception of melatonin, especially with long-term use. An analysis reviewing the health records of over 130,000 adults with insomnia found that those with documented long-term melatonin use (12 months or longer) had a 90% higher incidence of new heart failure compared to non-users. They were also nearly twice as likely to die of any cause. Experts caution that since melatonin is often taken nightly for months or years without medical supervision, and given its unregulated status, caution is necessary. Moreover, experts suggest avoiding excessive use to prevent interference with the body’s natural melatonin production.
Magnesium, L-Theanine and Glycine: Promoting Relaxation and Sleep Function
Several other Natural Supplements can help improve sleep by targeting physiological processes related to relaxation, neurological function, and sleep cycle maintenance.
Magnesium
Magnesium is a mineral that plays a crucial role in brain function, helping to regulate chemicals associated with relaxation and sleepiness; it is also involved in the synthesis of melatonin. This supplement is widely believed to improve both the quantity and quality of sleep. Magnesium’s muscle-relaxing properties may benefit individuals prone to muscle cramps at bedtime or those with restless legs syndrome. Research indicates that people who do not get sufficient sleep may have lower levels of magnesium in their bodies.
A special formulation, magnesium-L-threonate (MgT), is noted for its potential to better penetrate the brain where it is needed. Studies have investigated MgT supplementation (1 gram per day, taken two hours before bedtime) in adults reporting poor sleep quality. For those seeking magnesium for sleep purposes, magnesium glycinate is considered the best form of this mineral.
L-Theanine
L-theanine is a unique, non-protein, water-soluble amino acid found characteristically in tea plants. It is recognized for its neuroprotective and anti-anxiety effects. L-theanine contributes to mental protection against adverse stress.
In relation to sleep, L-theanine acts synergistically with other calming compounds. For example, when combined with GABA (gamma-aminobutyric acid), L-theanine demonstrated a positive synergistic effect on sleep behavior, including improvements in sleep quality and duration. This mechanism may involve the promotion of GABA receptor expression.
Glycine
Glycine is an amino acid supplement. Research has found that consuming 3 grams of glycine before bedtime can enhance sleep quality, reduce symptoms of insomnia, and help maintain a healthy sleep cycle.
Valerian: The Evidence Gap Between Popularity and Efficacy
Valerian root (Valeriana officinalis) is an herb that is widely available in commercial preparations and is commonly marketed and used as a popular sleep aid. In 2005, valerian was among the top-selling herbs in the U.S., with estimated sales totaling $3.4 million.
However, despite its popularity, current evidence does not support the clinical efficacy of valerian as a sleep aid for treating disturbed sleep or insomnia. A comprehensive review concluded that while the herb is associated with only rare adverse events and is generally safe, the evidence fails to support its use.
Challenges in Research Findings
The research on valerian is complicated by the pronounced heterogeneity among studies, varying widely in preparation techniques, species used (e.g., V. officinalis vs. V. edulis), dosage, and patient characteristics.
• Ethanolic Extracts: Several rigorous studies investigating ethanolic extracts (such as LI 156) found no significant difference between valerian and placebo on objective sleep outcomes (measured by polysomnography, or PSG) or subjective sleep ratings in subjects with or without insomnia. In some trials, valerian improved subjective sleep quality in a manner equivalent to certain benzodiazepines, but these results rely on the assumption that the tested benzodiazepines were superior to placebo.
• Aqueous Extracts: Studies on aqueous extracts yielded mixed results. Short-term use (one to four nights) did not show significant effects on PSG or subjective sleep outcomes in healthy subjects. However, one study using wrist actigraphy (movement detectors) suggested that aqueous valerian extracts reduced sleep onset latency in persons with sleep onset problems, but the reduction was small (only four to six minutes).
• Valepotriate Preparations: Studies using preparations standardized to high valepotriate content (found in species like V. edulis) also provided limited and varied evidence of mild reduction in sleep disturbances.
• Combination Products: When valerian was combined with other sedative herbs like hops or lemon balm, the overall findings remained predominantly negative. Placebo-controlled studies of valerian–hops combinations generally failed to show improvement in objective (PSG) or subjective outcomes in subjects with insomnia. One exception: a valerian–lemon balm combination reduced subjective sleep latency and increased subjective sleep quality in patients with insomnia.
Methodological Concerns
A significant issue that complicates older valerian studies is the failure to adequately mask the treatments. Valerian has a distinctive, unpleasant odor, and failure to mask this odor or odorize the placebo may increase participants’ expectations, thereby enhancing the placebo effect. The most methodologically rigorous studies, particularly the most recent ones, generally found no significant effects of valerian on sleep.
Safety Profile
Valerian is generally considered safe. The most common side effects are mild, including neurological symptoms (dizziness, headache, drowsiness) or gastrointestinal (GI) symptoms (nausea, diarrhea). Dose-dependent hangover effects, such as increased morning sleepiness, have been reported with higher doses (900mg) of aqueous extracts. Valerian causes little to no impairment of performance, especially when compared to prescription benzodiazepines.
Other Supporting Natural Supplements
Beyond the core supplements, other vitamins, minerals, and compounds may play a supportive role in enhancing rest:
• Iron Supplements: Iron may be beneficial for individuals whose sleep patterns are disrupted by restless legs syndrome.
• Vitamin D: Research suggests that Vitamin D supplementation may help individuals with low vitamin D levels fall asleep faster and sleep longer.
• CBD: Cannabidiol (CBD), a compound found in hemp and marijuana that does not cause intoxication, shows initial promise as a potential insomnia treatment. However, comprehensive safety and effectiveness studies are still needed.
Important Considerations for Natural Supplement Use
While Natural Supplements are generally considered safer and less likely to be habit-forming than prescription sleep medications, certain precautions must be followed to ensure the best results and minimize risk when aiming to improve sleep.
Consulting a Healthcare Provider
It is vital to consult a healthcare provider before starting any Natural Supplement regimen. Discussing the use of supplements allows for proper assessment of potential interactions with existing medications or underlying health conditions. Taking supplements without consultation can sometimes allow serious medical conditions or underlying sleep disorders (like sleep apnea) to go undiagnosed.
Interactions and Contraindications
Some supplements, such as melatonin or magnesium, may interact with prescription medications, potentially enhancing sedative effects. Specifically, valerian should not be taken with benzodiazepines or other sedating substances, such as antihistamines or alcohol, due to the risk of over-sedation. Furthermore, individuals with a history of liver disease or those at risk for liver dysfunction should exercise caution when using valerian.
✨ Want Faster, Deeper Sleep?
If you’re serious about fixing your sleep naturally, consider trying Sleep Hacking. It’s a complete, step-by-step blueprint that helps you shut down nighttime overthinking, calm your mind, and fall asleep up to 4× faster — backed by neuroscience.
👉 Discover the full program here: Sleep Hacking
Conclusion
In conclusion, the field of Natural Supplements offers several promising avenues to improve sleep, particularly through the use of herbs like Ashwagandha and minerals like Magnesium, which have demonstrated significant positive effects in clinical trials. While popular options like valerian have limited supporting evidence and melatonin carries risks associated with chronic use, specific, evidence-backed regimens, especially those involving targeted supplementation and good lifestyle habits can be an effective strategy for restoring restful nights.
